8 replies to this topic

[Bridog7]

Who is the best goalie off all time. Me and my dad argue about this topic. I say roy he says hasek.

[fumbler]

brodeur, i lost respect for both roy and hasek - i think mostly because their ego's got so big later on in their careers. roy was my fav player for many many years. was it roy that turned down team canada so he could focus on the prepping for the stanley cup or was that another goalie? i think that was my tsn turning point if it was him.

[Bridog7]

Roy has 4 cups 3 conn smythes on 2 different teams and started off his career in a higher scoring era. Brodeur has been on a defensive style team his whole career. I'd say hasek is better than brodeur because 2 mvps 6 vezina's. Also highest save % of all time.

[fumbler]

Milestones

Brodeur is the youngest goaltender in NHL history to reach the 300, 400 and 500 regular season win plateaus. His 300th victory came on December 15, 2001, with a 39-save shutout against the Ottawa Senators at the Corel Centre. His 400th victory was on March 23, 2004, at the Office Depot Center in Sunrise, Florida, as the Devils defeated the hometown Florida Panthers. Brodeur stopped twenty-one shots, and needed to work overtime to get the win. With the victory he also became the first goaltender to win 400 games with one team.[5] Brodeur reached the 500 win plateau on November 17, 2007, against the Philadelphia Flyers, with a 6 to 2 win. On March 15, 2008, he earned his seventh 40-win season of his career, the most of any goaltender in NHL history.
On March 14, 2009, Brodeur recorded his 551st career win against the Montreal Canadiens at the Bell Centre to tie Patrick Roy for the most in NHL history. To acknowledge their fellow countryman, the crowd of Canadiens fans chanted Brodeur's name at the end of the game and gave him a standing ovation. Brodeur's father Denis was at the game taking pictures.[57]
On March 17, 2009, in a 3–2 win over the Chicago Blackhawks, Brodeur became the all-time NHL leader in regular season wins by a goaltender with 552.
On November 27, 2009, Brodeur broke the record for most minutes ever played by an NHL goaltender, breaking Patrick Roy's record of 60,235.[58]
On December 7, 2009, Brodeur tied Sawchuk's record for regular season shutouts at 103 in a 3–0 victory over the Buffalo Sabres. Eleven days later, Brodeur broke the record set by Patrick Roy for games played by a goaltender in the National Hockey League (1,030 games).
On December 21, 2009, Brodeur recorded his 104th regular season shutout, breaking Sawchuk's record with a 4–0 victory over the Pittsburgh Penguins. He stopped all 35 shots.
Records

In over 14 seasons with the New Jersey Devils, Brodeur owns several notable NHL records lists as listed below.

Career





The final seconds and post-game celebration of Brodeur's 552nd win on March 17, 2009 against the Chicago Blackhawks at the Prudential Center.


Except as noted, these records include performance through the end of the 2008–09 season. Statistics for the current (2009–10) season will be updated upon its completion.

• Most regular season wins (586)
  
• Most shutouts (record achieved during 2009–10 season)
  
• Most shutouts, regular season & playoffs combined (130)
  
• Most 5 or more shutouts in one season (11)
  
• Most overtime wins (45)
  
• Most consecutive 30-win seasons (12)
  
• Most consecutive 35-win seasons (11)
  
• Most 40-win seasons (7)
  
• Most games played by an NHL goaltender (record achieved during 2009–10 season)
  
• Most total minutes played by an NHL goaltender (record achieved during 2009–10 season)
  
• Only NHL goalie to score a game-winning goal
  
• One of two NHL goalies (Ron Hextall) to score a goal in both the regular season and the playoffs

Regular season

• Most wins in a single season (48, in 2006–07)
  
• Most minutes played in a single season (4697, in 2006–07)

Playoffs

• Most shutouts in a playoff season (7, in 2002–03)
  
• Most shutouts in playoffs, career: (23, tied with Patrick Roy)
  
• Most shutouts in a Stanley Cup final (3, in 2002–03; tied with Toronto Maple Leafs' Frank McCool)
  
• 2nd place: 98 Wins
  
• 3rd goaltender to win the Stanley Cup with a Game-7 shutout in 2002–03.
  
• 1st goaltender in history to have 3 shutouts in two different playoff series. (1995 against Boston in the Conference Quarterfinals, 2003 against Anaheim in the Stanley Cup final.)
  
• Most consecutive playoff starts: 157,(1995-2009)

Brodeur has also acquired more than 30 franchise records, including most all-time, regular season and playoff wins, shutouts, games lowest goals-against-average.
Awards

• Calder Memorial Trophy — 1994
  
• NHL 1st All-Star Team — 2003, 2004, 2007
  
• NHL 2nd All-Star Team — 1997, 1998, 2006, 2008
  
• NHL All-Rookie Team — 1994
  
• NHL All-Star Game — 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2003, 2004, 2007, 2008
  
• Olympic gold medal — 2002
  
• Primus World'Stars Challenge Bowl — 2004
  
• QMJHL 2nd All-Star Team — 1992
  
• QMJHL All-Rookie Team — 1990
  
• Stanley Cup — 1995, 2000, 2003
  
• Vezina Trophy — 2003, 2004, 2007, 2008
  
• William M. Jennings Trophy — 1997 (with Mike Dunham), 1998, 2003 (tied Roman Čechmánek & Robert Esche), 2004
  
• World Cup of Hockey championship — 2004

Source: Martin Brodeur - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Edited by fumbler, 16 January 2010 - 08:28 AM.
formatting

[fumbler]

Milestones

• His jersey number 30 has been retired by the Granby Bisons.
  
• His jersey number 33 has been retired by the Colorado Avalanche and the Montreal Canadiens.
  
• In 1998, he was ranked number 22 on The Hockey News' list of the 100 Greatest Hockey Players.
  
• The Colorado Sports Hall Of Fame 2004.
  
• QMJHL Hall of Fame.
  
• Hockey Hall of Fame inductee 2006.
  
• Was ranked #5 in The Hockey News' The Top 60 Since 1967 – The Best Players of the Post Expansion Era.

Records

• Most NHL playoff games played by a goaltender (247) (second most playoff games of all players).
  
• Most combined wins (regular season and playoffs) by an NHL goaltender (702).
  
• Most NHL playoff wins by a goaltender (151).
  
• Most Conn Smythe Trophy wins (3).
  
• Most NHL playoff shutouts (23) – tied with Martin Brodeur.

Awards

• Calder Cup – with Sherbrooke Canadiens in 1985
  
• Stanley Cup — with Montreal Canadiens in 1986, 1993, with Colorado Avalanche in 1996, 2001
  
• Conn Smythe Trophy — 1986, 1993, 2001
  
• William M. Jennings Trophy — 1987*, 1988*, 1989*, 1992, 2002
  
• Vezina Trophy — 1989, 1990, 1992
  
• NHL All-Star Game — 1988, 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994, 1997, 1998, 2001, 2002, 2003
  
• NHL 1st All-Star Team — 1989, 1990, 1992, 2002
  
• NHL 2nd All-Star Team — 1988, 1991
  
• NHL All-Rookie Team — 1986
  
• Trico Goaltending Award — 1989, 1990
  
• Memorial Cup in 2006 with Quebec Remparts (as the Coach)
  
• Montreal Canadiens retired Roy's No. 33 jersey on November 22, 2008

* Shared with Brian Hayward.

Source: Patrick Roy - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[fumbler]

Milestones

Hašek earned his 300th National Hockey League win on October 15, 2005, in a 5–1 home victory with the Ottawa Senators over the Boston Bruins. He stopped 34 of 35 shots and was holding a shutout until Bruins forward Pat Leahy jammed a loose puck under him three minutes into the third period. He became the twenty-second goaltender to reach the milestone.[7] He is the oldest goaltender in NHL history to post a 30-win season, and in 1997, he became the first goaltender to win the Lester B. Pearson Award for most outstanding player in the league. He is also the only goaltender to win the Hart Trophy twice for most valuable player, and was only one Vezina Trophy away from tying Jacques Plante's record of seven. Hašek's personal best shutout streak is 181 minutes, 17 seconds.
Records

In nine seasons with the Buffalo Sabres, Hašek acquired over 25 franchise records, including most all-time games played, wins, shutouts and lowest goals against average.[21] He also holds the Sabres' record for most shutouts in a single season with 13 in 1997–98, and lowest goals against average in a single season with a total of 1.87 in 1998–99. During the Detroit Red Wings' championship run in 2002, Hašek set franchise records for most games played, minutes played, wins and shutouts in a playoff year. He holds several notable NHL records:
GeneralBefore retirement

• 3rd place – Most shutouts of all active players
  
• 4th place – Most wins of all active players

All-time

• 1st place – Highest career save percent (.922)
  
• 1st place – Most games played by a European
  born goaltender (694)
  
• 6th place – Most shutouts (81)
  
• 8th place – Lowest goals against average (2.20)
  
• 10th place – Most wins (389)

Regular season

• First European goalie to lead the NHL in GAA (1993–94)
  
• First goalie since 1974 to have a GAA below 2.00 (1993–94)
  
• Most shutouts in one month (six in 97–98)

PlayoffsBefore retirement

• 3rd place – Most shutouts of all active players (15)
  
• 4th place – Most wins of all active players (61)

All-time

• 2nd place – Most shutouts in one season (6)
  
• 3rd place – Most shutouts (15)
  
• 10th place – Most wins (61)

Source: Dominik Hašek - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[Bridog7]

Hasek is better than brodeur. Both have zero conn smythe's but hasek was never given the chance to win one since he was on buffalo. Brodeur has the wins and shutout record because he's been on a defensive style team his whole career. I think the battle should be between Roy and Hasek.

[Bridog7]

Roy defeated brodeur in the 01 cup finals

[ovie_8]

1.Roy
2.Brodeur
3.Hasek
If brodeur gets a gold medal or a cup or a conn smythe than i will put brodeur as the best. but for now it is Roy! Also brodeur never won vezina until hasek and roy retired plus no conn smythe's and less cups than roy. Roy has the most conn smythe's out of any player/goalie. Also roy has the most playoff wins and most wins combined season/playoffs